I wrote at the end of last summer, and it was just published in #90 of Canadian Notes and Queries.
Please check out the magazine, and send them funds to cover an annual subscription - from now until the end of time.
I reviewed Moore's novel February in 2009 on this blog.
*
Caught
By
Lisa Moore
Anansi,
2013
Fifteen
months ago I was sitting outside Sunnybrook General Hospital in Toronto with my
wife. She was in a wheelchair. She had just had a chemotherapy treatment, her
last. She was in a wheelchair because her breast cancer had spread to her liver
and then her bones. Her T1 vertebrae fractured. She took a series of high
powered pain killers and that day was streaming hydromorphine (seven times more
powerful than morphine) into her abdomen through a catheter. She could stand,
but barely walk. The chemotherapy was for a resurgence of cancer in her liver.
It was a last ditch effort to extend, not save, her life, however briefly.
Before the chemotherapy, Kate had pulled up her blood results from that morning
on her ipad (yay, e-health). They were not good. The one number we’d been told
to watch, that we were hoping was at least stable from a week earlier, that we
were hoping most of all would go down, had doubled.
“I guess this is it,” she said.
“Do you want to go through with the chemo?”
I asked.
“Might as well,” she said. “We’re here.”
She had the treatment, then I wheeled her
out into the sunshine and called the private ambulance company I’d hired to
transport her that day. I have 24 steps from the sidewalk to my front door.
Kate couldn’t do it anymore. I needed someone to carry her up the stairs.
The ambulance didn’t come until three hours
later.
It was the last time we were alone together.
It was a Friday. She died the following Wednesday.
It was the time to say those things. I can
tell you there isn’t much to say at that point, except reiterating love. I
said, “I wish this moment would last forever. Just you and me, right here,
right now. It’s not the disease that’s the enemy. It’s time.”
We can’t stop tomorrow from coming.
We said some other things. It was a lovely
moment. A grain of sand in the ocean of time.
Lisa Moore’s fiction, all of it, is full of
such moments. She is an expert at stopping the clock and forcing the reader to
focus on the intense swirl of details locked into an instant.
In a review of Moore’s Giller-nominated
short story collection, Open
(Anansi, 2002), I wrote: “Moore's stories are fragmented like memories. They
have a coherence from beginning to end, but in the middle the reader is often
jarred by the sudden, apparently random, thoughts of the characters.”
In a review of Moore’s novel, February (Anansi, 2009), I wrote of
what I called “Moore’s genius”: “The structure of time, the implications of
time, is perhaps Lisa Moore's primary narrative obsession. ... Moore's style
and attention to the details of her character's specifics, focus the reader's
attention on the here and now, while also allowing the past and future to
resonate.”
Which is to say that I disagree with the
pull quote on the cover of Moore’s new novel, Caught (Anansi, 2013). The quote, by Patrick deWitt, calls the new
novel, “A propulsive and harrowing read.” Harrowing is okay. Propulsive,
however, the novel is surely not.
Nor should it be.
Though let’s first judge a book by its
cover. The girl in the red bikini, standing in the big-waved surf, sailboat on
the horizon, large red italicized CAUGHT weighing down on the ocean like a
primeval sun. Yum. Propulsive. But that’s not what this book is about.
This book is about David Slaney, a
24-year-old convicted drug smuggler, who breaks out of prison after four years
on the inside and is on the run on page one. Where is he running? To find his
old mate, Brian Hearn, who skipped bail on the original charges and is now
living under a false identity and, get this, studying to become an English
professor.
The largest part of the book focuses on
Slaney’s trek, east to west, as he seeks to meet up with Hearn, who has a new
smuggling operation planned, one that doesn’t include getting caught. Slaney’s
job will be to lead the operation on the sailboat (see cover), meet up with a
militia in South America, trade cash for a whack of marijuana, and slip back up
the (west) coast (this time). Millionaires, they will be. Set for life on the
lam.
The frame of the plot is high adventure, but
for all of the revving of engines, it never picks up speed. Slaney’s journey
west is episodic, as Moore deep dives into scene after scene. The writing in these
scenes is sharp and intense. As discussed above, Moore is able to stop the
clock through an expert use of repetition and a journalistic eye for detail.
Like Jeff Wall, she takes miniature moments and blows them up to enormous
scale. The scenes are also often highly cinematic.
For example, Slaney stops at a hotel where
he trades labour for room and board. On the eve before he’s scheduled to leave,
he catches wind that there are police in the building. He doubles back and
seeks escape. He travels along a floor that houses guests from a wedding. A
door opens and the bride, inside alone, asks him to enter and help zip up her
dress. They hear the police pounding on doors along the hallway. Slaney hides
and the bride assures the officers that all is well within. Slaney wishes the
bride well on her journey, and she wishes him well on his.
“It’s only pot,” is repeated more than once.
To which the refrain is, boys, you knew the
risk.
But as the bride story illustrates, Slaney
is no gangster. In fact, the arc of the story is more folk tale than novel.
Slaney doesn’t go through a transformative learning curve, reaching a climax of
confidence that leads to crisis and resolution. He gets batted around like one
of Lear’s flies to wanton gods. He’s just a good old boy, never meaning no
harm. He’s not even a red neck.
Women, it must be said, love him. He gets
laid with rapid frequency.
Is he a kind of idealized boy-man?
Slaney is the one the title refers to. He is
the caught one. But he is also the one who is most free. He makes no
compromises. He never negotiates his integrity.
He is like Pretty Boy Floyd, except he
lives.
Hearn, on the other hand, skips bail,
bankrupts his father, lives a notoriously open life for a “most wanted” man. He
grew up with Slaney, and they were best buds, but the connection between them
is never proven; it is only asserted. Readers will have no trouble
understanding the attractiveness of Slaney. Hearn, however, reeks of a slime
ball, however well read. Why does Slaney risk it all for this man? Why is it
Slaney who is always the one putting himself at the forefront of harm’s way?
The questions are never answered satisfactorily.
The girl on the cover, for example, is a
passenger in the sailboat. There wasn’t supposed to be a passenger. There
wasn’t supposed to be a girl. Hearn isn’t as in control of the details as he
should be as a hands on project manager. Slaney is the muscle; Hearn,
logistics. Slaney trusts Hearn implicitly, but his trust isn’t earned.
So let’s get to the end. Spoiler alert. Stop
here if you would prefer not to know.
The rendezvous in South America succeeds.
Along the Mexican coast, they hit a hurricane, which they are lucky to survive,
but the sails are torn to shreds. They need to go into port. They are held by
the authorities. The gig is up, surely, except, no, it isn’t, because Hearn’s
operation has been infiltrated by the police, and the police want Slaney back
in Canada, so they can complete their arrest. Deals are made, and the Mexican’s
release the crew and their cargo, and out to sea they go, but they know
something is up because a cop talks to the girl and tells her she can get off
if she cooperates.
Slaney decides on a bold move. They will
reverse course, go through the Panama Canal, and head home, to Newfoundland.
This is a brilliant plot twist and it had me riveted, but by this part of the
novel Moore had dropped the time pause techniques and only a few pages later
Slaney was in handcuffs in the back of a squad car. Hearn got off on a
technicality. Slaney did 20 years and in 1998 he gets out and heads back to the
Rock to whittle away his days.
He visits the local university and the
English Department, which is the new home of Dr. Brian Hearn.
I didn’t like this ending. It came too
swiftly. It came because of betrayal, the girl’s. Slaney, as a character, I
felt, deserved better. He deserved to at least reach Newfoundland and have a
taste of success. One roaring party on the beach, say. I would have held in
there for another 100 pages for that, even if he got caught in the morning,
hung over and stoned. Instead, he and his mates are swiftly rounded up upon
arrival and the prospect of a Grand Finale fizzles, and I closed the book
feeling sour and disappointed, despite enjoying most of it and admiring same.
To add insult to injury, Hearn, the bastard,
gets to teach iambs to undergraduates.
Hey, that’s no way to say goodbye.
